Tiramisu
US$11.25
Milkshakes
US$11.25
House Gelato Selection
US$8.75
Panna Cotta
US$10.00
Explore a diverse menu at Thick and Thin Pizza, located at 1302 Myrtle Ave in Brooklyn. Each dish tells a story, from classic Italian pizzas to comforting pasta dishes. Dive into the artisan pizzas with a choice of thin-Romana or thick-Detroit styles. Indulge in the creamy panna cotta or the rich tiramisu for dessert. Each item is priced reasonably, averaging $12.19, ensuring you enjoy a fantastic meal without breaking the bank.
Vegetarian options shine here, such as the Caprese Salad and Fettuccine Pesto. Meat lovers should try the Meatball Sandwich or the Tagliatelle Bolognese.
The menu spots a unique blend of conventional and innovative offerings, allowing everyone to find something special. Don't forget to pair your meal with a refreshing Italian soda or a delicious mocktail.





The ambiance at Thick and Thin Pizza creates a warm and inviting space for all diners. Decorated with rustic Italian accents and cozy seating, this restaurant embodies a friendly neighborhood eatery vibe. It’s a great place to hang out with friends or enjoy a comforting meal alone.
The open kitchen concept enhances the dining experience, allowing patrons to observe the artistry behind each pizza and pasta dish. The aromas wafting through the air set the mood for a memorable meal. Enjoy the casual yet lively atmosphere, where laughter and good conversations flow as freely as the fantastic food.

Thick and Thin Pizza stands out in the Brooklyn culinary scene. The restaurant excels in offering a vibrant mix of traditional and contemporary Italian dishes. Pizza lovers will revel in their array of artisan pies, whether you crave a classic Margherita or want to experience the indulgent Caramelized Truffle pizza, a community favorite.
The meatball dish here deserves a spotlight, often highlighted during local iftar events for its rich flavors and comforting vibes. Pair it with a side of their Antipasto Sharing Board for an authentic Italian experience. Desserts like panna cotta add a delightful end to your meal, ensuring every visit leaves you satisfied and eager for more.

Thick and Thin Pizza prides itself on its commitment to quality and authenticity in every bite. The specialty lies in crafting delicious dishes that respect traditional Italian roots while embracing new flavors and ideas. From the rich, rustic pasta to the sensational pizzas, every plate is a testament to culinary passion and expertise. The vision extends beyond just serving meals. The aim is to create a space where community members enjoy great food and connect over shared experiences. Consistently delivering outstanding service elevates the dining experience, ensuring that each visit feels special.