Thick and Thin Pizza

Experience authentic Italian flavors at Thick and Thin Pizza in Brooklyn. Savor our delicious truffle, pepperoni, meatball sandwiches, panna cotta, and more. Visit us at 1302 Myrtle Ave or call +1 347-240-0742 for a memorable dining experience!

Welcome to Thick and Thin Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Thick and Thin Pizza
Thick and Thin Pizza
Thick and Thin Pizza
Thick and Thin Pizza

Thick and Thin Pizza stands as a beloved destination in Brooklyn, NY, at 1302 Myrtle Ave. With a menu that marries traditional Italian flavors with a modern twist, this restaurant draws in food lovers and casual diners alike. You can’t miss the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air as you approach. From the delicate truffle notes in their pasta to the rich flavor of thick Detroit-style pizzas, each dish aims to please.

Customers rave about the cozy atmosphere, warm service, and the joyful spirit that fills the space during meals. The restaurant’s average price of around $12.19 ensures that anyone can enjoy a slice of Italy without breaking the bank.

Thick and Thin Pizza boasts an impressive variety of 55 carefully crafted plates, making it a true culinary playground. With categories ranging from hearty pasta dishes like Spaghetti & Meatballs to artisan pizzas showcasing trendy toppings like caramelized truffle and pesto with ricotta, there’s something for everyone. Additionally, the dessert selection shines with delights such as panna cotta and decadent tiramisu that perfectly round off any meal.

The restaurant’s focus on quality ingredients ensures a dining experience that leaves patrons craving more. Seasonal mocktails and Italian sodas add a unique touch to the beverage menu, catering to both adults and kids alike. The inviting interior, paired with the dedicated service, creates a community vibe where guests feel at home.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

1302 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11221, United States

Phone

+1 347-240-0742

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Thick and Thin Pizza
Thick and Thin Pizza
Thick and Thin Pizza
Thick and Thin Pizza

Thick and Thin Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a culinary experience that reflects the heart of authentic Italian cuisine infused with Brooklyn spirit. Opened as a humble slice shop, it has grown into a local favorite thanks to its dedication to quality and innovation. The diverse menu includes an outstanding selection of pizzas, ranging from traditional thin-Romana styles to thick-Detroit style, satisfying a variety of palates. Diners admire the meticulous craftsmanship that goes into each dish, especially the standout meatball sandwich.

At an average price of $12.19, diners receive excellent value—offering generous portions without sacrificing quality.

The concept here goes beyond just food. Locals gather to share meals and stories, making it a community hub where the essence of Brooklyn's culture shines through. The servers greet returning patrons by name, fostering a neighborhood atmosphere that keeps everyone coming back. The restaurant hosts themed nights and special events, creating opportunities for the community to come together over their shared love for great food.

Whether a casual dinner after a long day or a special gathering with family, Thick and Thin Pizza accommodates every occasion.

While the menu varies, one can always expect dishes thoughtfully prepared with fresh ingredients that reflect the seasons. Traditional Italian methods shine through, paired with unique interpretations that showcase modern culinary techniques. Daily specials often highlight seasonal produce, encouraging adventure for those looking to explore new flavors. The restaurant’s commitment to sustainability is evident, sourcing local ingredients when possible, thus reducing its carbon footprint and supporting neighboring businesses. Overall, dining at Thick and Thin Pizza is not just about satisfying hunger; it’s a celebration of food, community, and culture.

Thick and Thin Pizza

Thick and Thin Pizza presents a charming exterior that invites diners in with its vibrant, welcoming façade. Situated on Myrtle Avenue, the restaurant’s windows showcase mouth-watering pizzas and desserts, enticing passersby to step inside. Outdoor seating allows guests to indulge al fresco, perfect for enjoying that Brooklyn sunshine while savoring a meal. The neighborhood vibe enhances the experience, featuring local artwork on the walls and street musicians occasionally providing a lively soundtrack. This vibrant energy reflects Brooklyn’s diverse culture, making each visit a feast for the senses.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-12 AM
  • Monday11 AM-10 PM
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-10 PM
  • Friday11 AM-12 AM
  • Saturday11 AM-12 AM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Very tasty, and staff is very nice!

G
Gulnora K.

We stumbled upon this new Italian restaurant and got really excited. We ended up going twice in a single week because it was so good! Their thin-crust pizza is delicious; we got the carbonara (best eaten right away) and the black truffle mushroom (tastes great both fresh and as heated leftovers). The next time we came, we got the meatball sandwich and the fettuccine Alfredo (with added sausage), both of which were fantastic. The pasta plate is big, which makes the portion look small, but it's really not. I had leftovers. Our servers were incredibly attentive and the food came out quickly. This is definitely becoming one of our favorite spots!

W
Wendy L.

Best pizza in the Neighbourhood

k
khalid a.

Only a few words to describe this place: - Good Food - Good Service - Good Ambiance

A
Akber M.

Finally a good pizza spot near Myrtle/Dekalb corner! Will be going back to try the pasta.

J
Joseph A.

You have to try the lasagna here--it's a must. And don't forget to ask for a sprinkle of shredded parsley and a bit of cheese on top... it takes the whole dish to another level.

M
Mahmoud W.